• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

bel posto wantaght: Authentic Italian Pasta & Specialty Slices in Wantagh, NY

Bel Posto Wantagh, located in Wantagh, NY, offers generous portions of authentic Italian cuisine that balance quality with quantity. Known for their specialty slices, crispy rice balls, and hearty pasta, this spot delivers satisfying meals that leave you full yet eager for more. The welcoming atmosphere, spacious dining area, and attentive staff enhance the experience, making each visit pleasant. While prices lean toward fine dining, the flavor and service justify the cost. Signature dishes like steak with mashed potatoes and fresh salads stand out, reflecting the chef’s passion and care. Bel Posto Wantagh is a must-visit for Long Island Italian food lovers.

bel posto wantaght at a glance

  • Address 3453 Merrick Rd, Wantagh, NY 11793, United States
  • Phone +1 516-407-3677
  • Restaurant type Pizza restaurant , Italian restaurant .

Photos & Gallery

bel posto wantaght: Reviews & Ratings

G
4

Very good and filling specialty slices. Plain slice was ok. Service was good, staff was friendly. Dining area is very spacious and accommodating. Parking can be limited when it's busy in that shopping strip, but there are enough parking spots available.

Ellen Holland
4

Our waitress was wonderful. It was her first night and she made the dining experience very nice. She went out of her way to make us feel comfortable and get is whatever we needed. The rolls were delicious, and the food was very good. My complaint is this... the upcharge for the house salad to the ceasar was $4.50! And the cappuccino was $7.50, and I didnt even like it! Too much milk. Bottom line, it's a pizza parlor with a small restaurant on the side. The prices were more like fine dining prices.

wen wen
4

Ok food. Cover melted and stick to the pasta from take out containers.

Genevive
5

The owner is absolutely wonderful! You can tell he cares about his customers. The best thing about this place is you don’t have to compromise quantity over quality. You get both!! Kudos to the chef The portions are good enough to make you feel full & the prices are perfect !! (I really hope they don’t change ) Definitely my favorite pasta spot in Long Island !!

Jennifer Morris
5

Went for an early dinner and we loved it! The Gorgonzola salad was one of the best we’ve ever had. The rice balls were crispy, cheesy and fresh. We also ordered the steak which came with yummy mashed potatoes and broccoli. The food was so delicious we forgot to take a picture of the steak, but it was equally as tasty as the apps. Our waiter, Carlos, was top notch. Super friendly and attentive from the minute we got there. We will definitely be going back!

Mia Monteleone
5

I came here with my family over the weekend and had a really great experience. The pasta was fresh, flavorful, and tasted homemade! The portions were perfect, and everything came out hot and well-seasoned. The atmosphere was cozy and the staff was super friendly without being overbearing. Overall, it’s a spot I’d definitely come back to! :)

Nicole Vasaturo
5

Under new ownership. The waitress and chef are very friendly. Pizza is very good. The brie salad is very delicious and very generous size. Hot antipasta was great. Prices are good. The $20 pasta special is great food is fresh and made with good quality ingredients. Will be coming back!

Andre Vialet
5

I was at the restaurant celebrating a birthday with a party of ten. I met the owner who impressed me with his enthusiasm and commitment to quality food and service. All the staff had the same enthusiasm. The food was great. We had a mix of family style and individual entrees. We were able to pair our own wine perfectly with the meal. I would highly recommend this restaurant.

Location

  • bel posto wantaght
    bel posto wantaght
    3453 Merrick Rd, Wantagh, NY 11793, United States Hotline: +1 516-407-3677

Bel Posto Wantagh, nestled on Merrick Road in Wantagh, NY, offers a refined take on classic pizza parlor fare with standout dishes that elevate the dining experience. Known primarily for its pizza, this restaurant surprises with a diverse menu that includes rich Chopped Lobster Pasta and comforting Eggplant Parmigiana, marrying quality ingredients with generous portions. The Hot and Sour Soup adds a delicate balance, showcasing the kitchen's skill in blending bold flavors with subtlety.

What truly impresses at Bel Posto Wantagh is the harmony between quantity and quality. The dishes arrive plentiful and satisfying without sacrificing taste or culinary finesse. The Chopped Lobster Pasta, for example, is a showcase of tender lobster pieces embedded in a well-seasoned sauce, creating a luxurious yet approachable dish. Meanwhile, the Eggplant Parmigiana strikes a perfect chord of crispiness and savory depth, making it a must-try for vegetable lovers and meat-eaters alike.

The dining ambiance is spacious and welcoming, contributing to a relaxed atmosphere where attentive, friendly staff enhance the experience. Service—highlighted by personable waiters like Carlos—lends a genuine warmth, making guests feel not just well served but truly valued. Though parking near the busy shopping strip can be tight at times, the availability of spots ensures convenience for most visits.

While some menu items reflect upscale pricing, such as the house-to-Caesar salad upcharge and cappuccino, the overall value is reinforced by the quality and portion sizes. The restaurant masterfully balances pizza parlor comfort with fine-dining touches, making it a unique destination on Long Island. Regulars praise its consistent delivery of hearty meals that satisfy both appetite and palate.

Bel Posto Wantagh stands as a culinary gem where Italian-American favorites meet thoughtful preparation and generous servings. Whether indulging in their specialty slices or savoring the full-bodied pastas, diners leave fulfilled and eager to return. It’s a place where the chef’s passion and the owner’s care resonate through every dish, crafting an experience that feels both authentic and exceptional.